| Peed DanielDirector, 10% owner · 68 transactions | — | 13.86M† | 43.8K | — | 131.6K |
| Branch Gregory CDirector · 35 transactions | — | 2.30M† | 240.0K | 542.7K | — |
| Pratt Gordon GReporting owner · 1 transaction | — | 2.13M†as of Sep 2008 | — | — | — |
| Poitevint Alec IIDirector · 78 transactions | — | 1.56M† | 65.0K | 1.15M | — |
| Hood III William H.Director · 42 transactions | — | 988.6K† | 112.4K | 718.2K | — |
| FMG Investors LLC10% owner · 1 transaction | — | 932.2Kas of Sep 2008 | — | — | — |
| Swets Larry G JrDirector · 1 transaction | — | 932.2Kas of Sep 2008 | — | — | — |
| Martz BradPresident & CEO · 73 transactions | — | 434.6K | 625.7K | 79.5K | 80.3K |
| Whittemore Kent GDirector · 38 transactions | — | 393.9K† | 65.0K | 117.8K | 4.5K |
| Hogan MichaelDirector · 50 transactions | — | 366.8K | 43.8K | 268.0K | — |
| Stilwell Joseph10% owner · 6 transactions | — | 357.7K†as of Oct 2012 | — | 12.0K | 2.7K |
| Davis Kern MichaelDirector · 47 transactions | — | 313.8K† | 65.0K | 209.4K | — |
| Stilwell Value LLC10% owner · 6 transactions | — | 239.9K†as of Oct 2012 | — | 12.0K | 2.7K |
| Synovus Financial Corp10% owner · 1 transaction | — | 220.0Kas of Sep 2011 | — | — | 1.54M |
| Gray James AndyChief Compliance/Risk Officer · 9 transactions | — | 210.5K | 57.9K | — | — |
| Hudson Sherrill WDirector · 37 transactions | — | 203.4Kas of May 2025 | 60.0K | 178.4K | 35.0K |
| Griffith ChristopherChief Operating Officer · 50 transactions | — | 145.5K | 494.3K | 45.0K | 335.6K |
| Shirazi BrookeChief Underwriting Officer · 4 transactions | — | 137.0K†as of Nov 2021 | — | 137.0K | — |
| Forney JohnPresident & CEO, Director · 29 transactions | — | 124.5Kas of Apr 2020 | 174.1K | 38.9K | — |
| Adler BrookeSecretary · 22 transactions | — | 124.1K | 194.6K | — | — |
| Maroney PatrickDirector · 22 transactions | — | 103.5K | 43.8K | 59.8K | — |
| Menon DeepakChief Revenue Officer · 40 transactions | — | 102.8Kas of Sep 2020 | 49.8K | 75.5K | — |
| Cronin Donald JChief Executive Officer, Director · 2 transactions | — | 91.4Kas of Mar 2009 | 12.5K | — | — |
| Salmon KimberlyGeneral Counsel · 26 transactions | — | 65.8K†as of Sep 2017 | 17.6K | 48.1K | — |
| Savage Neil W10% owner · 1 transaction | — | 61.5K†as of Sep 2011 | — | 10.0K | — |
| Griffin Nicholas WChief Financial Officer · 2 transactions | — | 58.3Kas of Mar 2009 | 12.5K | — | — |
| Russell Melvin A JrChief Underwriting Officer · 2 transactions | — | 49.0Kas of Dec 2012 | — | 1.6K | — |
| Swenson AndrewChief Information Officer · 12 transactions | — | 30.0Kas of May 2017 | 21.0K | 10.0K | — |
| St John ScottChief Claims Officer · 33 transactions | — | 25.7Kas of May 2022 | 16.4K | 13.7K | — |
| DiFrancesco Paul FChief Operating Officer · 13 transactions | — | 20.9Kas of Apr 2020 | 18.8K | 4.2K | — |
| Dittman ChristianChief Risk Officer · 1 transaction | — | 20.2Kas of Apr 2021 | — | — | — |
| Sargent Thomas DDirector · 1 transaction | — | 17.8Kas of Sep 2008 | — | — | — |
| Sturgess David EDirector · 1 transaction | — | 17.8Kas of Sep 2008 | — | — | — |
| Zuhlke JamesDirector · 1 transaction | — | 17.8Kas of Sep 2008 | — | — | — |
| Williams JayVice President of Sales · 4 transactions | — | 17.6Kas of Feb 2015 | 7.6K | 10.0K | — |
| Castle SvetlanaChief Financial Officer · 6 transactions | — | 16.4K | 27.9K | — | — |
| Langowski JohnVice President, Claims · 6 transactions | — | 14.7Kas of Mar 2016 | 16.7K | — | — |
| Crawford Troy JChief Underwriting Officer · 1 transaction | — | 12.6K | — | 3.2K | — |
| Weigley AlyciaChief Talent Officer · 2 transactions | — | 9.0Kas of Apr 2022 | 1.4K | — | — |
| Copechal JudyChief Underwriting Officer · 2 transactions | — | 3.3Kas of May 2015 | — | 75 | — |
| Brown Deirdre ADirector · 1 transaction | — | 1.5K | 5.0K | — | — |
| Kalter BradChief Legal Officer · 2 transactions | — | 661as of Apr 2020 | 944 | — | — |